Drats! Now the Pilgrims Were Grave Robbers

To all my friends in Blogland

Here’s hoping your Thanksgiving is blessed in every way!

Football, feasts, and family.

Thanksgiving is a time for us to give thanks.

Meanwhile back on the lecture circuit of Politically Correct- I found this lovely

Ah, historical revisionism enlightenment by way of the Madison (WI) Capital Times:


Patty Loew: Thanksgiving traditions all based on myths

By Mike Ivey

Everything you know about the “first” Thanksgiving is wrong.

Plymouth Rock.



Big feast.

Happy Indians sharing in the bounty.

It’s all bunk, except maybe the part about eating turkey. Early settlers were so hungry they ate about anything with fur or feathers.

Otherwise, there is little connection between reality and the version of Thanksgiving events still taught in most schools.

That point was hammered home Sunday by award-winning filmmaker Patty Loew.

A member of the Bad River Band of Lake Superior Ojibwe, Loew was the keynote speaker at the third annual “Interfaith Thanksgiving Celebration” held at Lakeview Lutheran Church on Madison’s north side.

Loew said the problem with the traditional Thanksgiving story is that it plays to the American version of history where peace loving English settlers tame the wilderness and survive attacks from the bloodthirsty Indians.

“It’s the quintessential American holiday,” she said. “It involves escaping danger, surviving in a harsh environment, carving out a new life.”

Unfortunately, Loew says, the whole Thanksgiving story is nothing but myth.

In reality, the Indian tribes living along the Eastern seaboard had been decimated by disease in the years preceding the storied landing at Plymouth Rock in 1620.

An epidemic of bubonic plague, most likely brought to the New World by European fishermen in 1617, had killed an estimated 90 percent of the Native population by the time the Pilgrims landed in Massachusetts.

“What the settlers found were empty villages with crops still in the field because the Indians had either died or left,” Loew said, quoting a version of event laid out by author James Loewen http://www.trinicenter.com/his…..giving.htm.

The more religious of the settlers — only 32 of the 102 who landed at Plymouth were actually Pilgrims — thought the existing villages and cleared fields were a sign that God was providing for them.

Other settlers took to digging up the graves of Indians, picking through the housewares, blankets or weapons buried with the dead.

So the first Thanksgiving in America was actually held by grave robbers,” Loew told the crowd of more than 200.

Loew challenged the audience to tell the correct version of events and think about what it means when they celebrate this Thursday with family or friends.

“We’re not just talking about feel good history, but history that reflects the truth,” said Loew, a longtime local TV anchor who serves as associate professor of life sciences communications at UW-Madison

If the crops were still standing in the fields and they were robbing graves, why didn’t the Pilgrims get the bubonic plague?

What would we ever do without associate professors of life science like Ms. Loew and “authors” like Mr. Lowen?

For the record, here are some other titles from this “author”:

This is just a multicultural curriculum which is designed to get as many little kids as possible to question the decency and the goodness of their own country.

Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong, Revised and Updated Edition by James W. Loewen (Hardcover – April 1, 2008)

Lies Across America: What American Historic Sites Get Wrong by James W. Loewen (Paperback – Oct 16, 2007)

Sundown Towns: A Hidden Dimension of American Racism by James W. Loewen (Paperback – Oct 3, 2006)

We Are the People: Voices from the Other Side of American History by Nathaniel May, Clint Willis, and James W. Loewen (Paperback – Oct 27, 2003)

The Mississippi Chinese : Between Black and White, Second Edition by James W. Loewen (Paperback – Jan 1988)

Lies My Teacher Told Me About Christopher Columbus: What Your History Books Got Wrong by James W. Loewen (Paperback – Jun 19, 1992)

Lies Across America: What Our Historic Sites Get Wrong by James W. Loewen (Paperback – Nov 14, 2000)

Everything You’ve Been Taught is Wrong (Portable Professor) by James W. Loewen (Audio CD – 2005) – Unabridged

One begins to detect a pattern.

  1. Families will tell the truth this Thanksgiving – including how the Plymouth colony was an abject failure under a communal system and only prospered when land owners were allowed to keep all they grew and sell it themselves.That truth also won’t include this revisionist garbage of the “Hate Americans First” crowd that, unfortunately, is becoming what’s taught in schools.All brought to you by – who else – a University professor.Your tax dollars at work, naturally.
  2. …..”Time to trash Thanksgiving……”My wife and I have been going to Montana for the past 13 summers doing volunteer work on the Blackfeet Reservation. Seldom, if ever, do we hear such garbage from the Indian population who, by the way, mostly prefer to be called “indian” rather than “native-American”. Having been adopted into the tribe after making many close friendships among the people, we hear the other side of the story from the “red” perspective. Readily admitted is the transgressions and prejudices perpetrated by parties on both sides of the issue.But as you have noted, the most biased and slanted perspectives will always be tendered by the “cultural elite”, most frequently academians and the media, or those with the means to influence a gullible public. One of my best friends among the Blackfeet is their tribal cultural historian, who says, both privately and publicly, that the only people insisting on being called ‘native Americans’ and taking offense at being called ‘indians’, are the “city indians” with an axe to grind. His wry comment is, he’s just glad Columbus wasn’t looking for the Virgin Islands or Turkey when he discovered the new world, otherwise we might be calling them something entirely different. In dialect, the Blackfeet refer to other ‘indians’ as “the people” and to themselves as “the REAL people.”Before someone jumps to any erroneus conclusions, this man is a highly educated, well-traveled, published author, lecturer, and producer of documentary films who lives a humble life both on and off the reservation. He’s also a Viet Nam veteran.I will accept his version of history in deference to that of a whole wagon-load of Patty Loews as being more genuine and untinged with a pre-conceived notion of victimhood.

There is some good stuff out there, my friends..

  1. Some recommended sites Thanksgiving HistoryThe Plymouth Thanksgiving Story – A very informative collection of information, including some challenging observations from a Native American viewpoint. Recommended reading!
  2. History.com has some fun videos and quizzes and a journal from one of the pilgrims.

Just like the Terminator, I will be back and visit you real soon. Promise. 🙂

Hugs to all of you! Leave your last post link for us to enjoy!


  1. Jeez Ange,
    I guess some people just have to see the dark side of everything, eh? Happy T.G. anyway, girl. Take care.


  2. The lies about our American heritage have been around for a long time. Now, at this very dangerous point in American history, the agenda of discrediting our heritage has ramped up.

  3. Happy Thanksgiving to one and all from the Tarheel State!

  4. Happy Thanksgiving to one and all from the Tarheel State!

  5. Happy Thanksgiving girlfriend!

  6. Always late to the party! Hope you had a good one, girl! Thinking of you!

    That Patty Loews sure is a wagon load, isn’t she?

  7. I just finished reading a great book on this subject. “Mayflower” by Nathaniel Philbrick. It’s a very balanced view of the origins of Plymouth colony and King Philip’s War from the settlers and the native perspective.

    I have read Loewen’s “Lies My Teacher Told Me”, and while it’s unapologetically leftist (i.e. a whole chapter on how socialism is better than capitalism) I think you guys would be surprised at some of the facts that aren’t taught in school. For instance, everyone knows the story of Helen Keller, but I had no idea that later in life she became a staunch socialist and was quite a controversial figure in her day. It made me interested to read more about a historical figure that I thought I pretty much had down pat.

    Anyway, I have a greater appreciation and understanding of Thanksgiving after reading “Mayflower”. I highly recommend it.

  8. Happy thanksgiving Angie, hope you are well.

  9. Just checking in, Miss Angie.

    Are you off getting your holiday mojo going???

  10. I hope your Thanksgiving was GREAT! I pray your Christmas is full of love and joy. And may your New Year be the best ever! Love ya, Deb

  11. Hiya Angie, hope you are well. Just wanted to wish you a merry Christmas and hope you’ll be back soon.

  12. Hey! Haven’t heard from you for a long while. I think I know. Get better! we miss you! –tracy

  13. Hey there! Thinking about you and praying for you! Hope your Christmas and New Year were bright and all good thinks in 2009! Love ya, Deb

  14. Hi Ang, hope you are doing ok these days. Miss ya!

  15. Thinking of you and missing you so much! Deb

  16. Angie,
    I hope that all is well with you.. I haven’t seen any posts for awhile.

    til later,
    from the mind of…

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s